Skip to content

A woman attained purity from menses right after dawn. Should she refrain from eating and drinking, as well as other invalidators of fast, and fast on that day so that it will be considered a day of valid fast for her, or would she have to make up for that day?

السؤال

Question no.1:

A woman attained purity from menses right after dawn. Should she refrain from eating and drinking, as well as other invalidators of fast, and fast on that day so that it will be considered a day of valid fast for her, or would she have to make up for that day?

س1: إذا طهرت الـمرأة بعد الفجر مباشرةً فهل تمسك وتصوم هذا اليوم، ويكون يومها لها، أو عليها قضاء ذلك اليوم؟

الجواب

Answer no.1:

There are two scholarly opinions regarding the case of a woman who attains purity from menses right after dawn:

First opinion: She is required to fast for the rest of that day, even though it will not be counted as a day of valid fast. As per the famous opinion of Imam Ahmad’s School of Fiqh, making up for that day is obligatory for her.

Second opinion: She is not required to fast for the rest of the day since it is not valid to fast on such a day when she was menstruating at its beginning. Hence, refraining from acts that invalidate the fast is pointless here. Moreover, she is obligated under Shariah to refrain from fasting at the beginning of that day; rather, it is prohibited for her to do so when she is still in menstruation, so it was not a time she had to show veneration by keeping away from fast invalidators.

According to Shariah, fasting is to refrain from all acts that invalidate the fast, as an act of worship to Allah Almighty, from the break of dawn till sunset.

As you can see, this opinion is more predominant than the other, which suggests she is required to fast for the rest of the day. Both opinions, however, make it obligatory for her to make up for that day.

ﺟ1: إذا طهرت المرأة بعد طلوع الفجر فللعلماء في إمساكها ذلك اليوم قولان:

القول الأول: أنه يلزمها الإمساك بقية ذلك اليوم، ولكنه لا يحسب لها، بل يجب عليها القضاء، وهذا هو المشهور من مذهب الإمام أحمد رحمه الله.

والقول الثاني: أنه لا يلزمها أن تمسك بقية ذلك اليوم؛ لأنه يومٌ لا يصحّ صومها فيه؛ لكونها في أوله حائضًا ليست من أهل الصّيام، وإذا لم يصح لم يبق للإمساك فائدةٌ، وهذا الزمن زمنٌ غير محترمٍ بالنّسبة لها؛ لأنها مأمورةٌ بفطره في أول النهار، بل محرمٌ عليها صومه في أول النهار،

والصوم الشرعيّ: هو الإمساك عن المفطّرات تعبّدًا لله عز وجل من طلوع الفجر إلى غروب الشمس.

وهذا القول -كما تراه- أرجح من القول بلزوم الإمساك، وعلى كلا القولين يلزمها قضاء هذا اليوم.