A woman attained purity from menses or post-partum bleeding at ‘Asr (afternoon) time. Is it due upon her to offer the Zhuhr (noon) prayer along with ‘Asr, or is she required to offer the ‘Asr prayer only?
السؤال
Question no.1:
A woman attained purity from menses or post-partum bleeding at ‘Asr (afternoon) time. Is it due upon her to offer the Zhuhr (noon) prayer along with ‘Asr, or is she required to offer the ‘Asr prayer only?
س12: إذا طهرت الحائض أو النّفساء وقت العصر، فهل تلزمها صلاة الظّهر مع العصر، أو لا يلزمها سوى العصر فقط؟
الجواب
Answer no.1:
The preponderant opinion in this issue is that it is due upon her to offer the ‘Asr prayer only due to the unavailability of proof obligating her to offer the Zhuhr prayer. Freedom from liability is the basic rule. The Prophet (may Allah’s peace and blessings be upon him) said:
“Whoever catches only one Rak‘ah (basic unit of prayer) of the ‘Asr prayer before sunset is considered to have caught the ‘Asr prayer (he has not missed it).”
The Hadīth does not state that one, in this case, has caught up with the Zhuhr prayer. If it were obligatory to pray Zhuhr, this would have been clarified by the Prophet (may Allah’s peace and blessings be upon him). Another proof is that if a woman has her menses after Zhuhr time, she is required to make up for the Zhuhr prayer only, even though Zhuhr and ‘Asr are combined together. This case is not different from that in question.
Hence, the preponderant opinion here is that such a woman is required to pray 'Asr only, based on the text's indication and by analogy. This also applies when she attains purity before the time of 'Ishā' prayer has elapsed since, in this case, she is required to pray 'Ishā' only, and the Maghrib prayer is not due upon her.
ﺟ12: القول الراجح في هذه المسألة: أنه لا يلزمها إلا العصر فقط؛ لأنه لا دليل على وجوب صلاة الظّهر، والأصل براءة الذّمة، ثم إن النبي ﷺ قال:
«مَنْ أَدْرَكَ رَكْعَةً مِنَ الْعَصْرِ قَبْلَ أَنْ تَغْرُبَ الشَّمْسُ فَقَدْ أَدْرَكَ الْعَصْرَ» [1]،
ولم يذكر أنه أدرك الظّهر، ولو كان الظّهر واجبًا لبينه النبيّ ﷺ، ولأن المرأة لو حاضت بعد دخول وقت الظّهر لم يلزمها إلا قضاء صلاة الظّهر دون صلاة العصر، مع أن الظّهر تجمع إلى العصر، ولا فرق بينها وبين الصّورة التي وقع السّؤال عنها.
[2] البخاري، كتاب الصوم، باب الحائض تترك الصوم والصلاة (1951).
وعلى هذا يكون القول الراجح أنه لا يلزمها إلا صلاة العصر فقط؛ لدلالة النصّ والقياس عليها، وكذلك الشأن فيما لو طهرت قبل خروج وقت العشاء، فإنه لا يلزمها إلا صلاة العشاء، ولا تلزمها صلاة المغرب.