What is it that is sometimes heard near the graves of some dead people who are revered by the ignorant?
السؤال
Q: What is it that is sometimes heard near the graves of some dead people who are revered by the ignorant?
الجواب
A:These are the voices of the devils and the jinn. They give the ignorant people an impression that these are the voices of the dead in their graves so that they may tempt them, confuse them in their religion, and lead them astray. The people in the graves do not hear, and they do not respond to those who supplicate them or call them. This is based on texts from the Noble Qur’an, in which Allah, the Exalted, said: {Indeed, you will not make the dead hear} [An-Naml: 80], and He also said: {If you invoke them, they do not hear your supplication} [Faatir: 14], and He also said: {But you cannot make hear those in the graves.} [Faatir: 22] So, how can the dead answer them when they are in the world of the Barzakh (interim life, after death and before resurrection) and they have no link with the people of this world? Allah, the Exalted, said: {ِِAnd they are unaware of their invocation.} [Al-Ahqaaf: 5]